[ he considers the sentry and the void, and whether or not either has the capacity for kindness. he recalls armand’s claim that the shadow’s intentions had been merciful. an easeful death.
maybe those who seek the dark will always think it kinder. ]
Such a strange question. Not a criticism. No one's ever asked me before.
[there's a smile on the other side, whether or not bob can guess at its existence. he tries to remember. 'nervous.' what a word.]
I'm afraid all the time. You can't care about something without being afraid to lose it. To believe otherwise disavows anything about people worth keeping.
[i don't plan to die would be redundant, probably, even if he failed to show off self-preservation maneuvers last time. what does the book say? is peripheral.]
Has the worst thing you know to fear happened to you yet?
[—feels like normal conversational progression to him, somehow. he hits send.]
That's wise to know about yourself. About everything you could lose. This is a better place to start from. More honest. Even if it's terrifying.
[that it can always be worse. half the horror of knowing what you're about is just horror. it's not alien to him, the need for reassurance. it doesn't seem weak in any way he eschews. the student wants to learn. that's the nature of the relationship—when you have the good fortune of not having to kill to claim what belongs with you.]
When I met you, you felt like someone who'd lost everything at some point. There's freedom in that. But I'm not trying to sell you nihilism or whatever the next philosopher will say. I just mean that it's opportunity to question the rules, the shape of the foundations, that built you in the first place.
Or not even opportunity. Necessity. Because you know it could happen again and time does not move in a circle. It's a spiral. You have a say in the direction of the drift, but none of us get to hide in a moment of reprieve.
What does this book say?
Edited (I decided to delete one mention of "book" at the risk of the tag making less sense) 2026-02-03 01:09 (UTC)
[ it’s a spiral, yes, it feels that way. florida riptide, red seaweed in the water. dragging you under, out, under, out, unless you flow with it. swim sideways. a day in the direction. logical, but alien, for one who has always been a passenger in his own life but can no longer afford to drift. ]
it says the shadow is neutral and it reflects what i put into it when i’m upset with it, it looks more frightening so i should be more open minded about it
[ but consider i would not be so pissed at that guy if he would be helpful for once ]
[ a pause to take in that approval (warm, appreciative) and the subsequent chaser. what sense is there in hiding? ]
i don’t know all the details the place i’m from had these heroes to protect us for a long time, from dangers that were bigger and more powerful all the time, but we lost a lot of them
so he wasn’t supposed to exist they were just trying to make somebody strong enough to protect everybody i wasn’t the guy they wanted it to work on either, more like the first draft
[ to be discarded. ]
Edited (dw ate half my tag ) 2026-02-04 10:20 (UTC)
My first master regretted making me what I am, too. Or she would've, if she were capable of questioning herself.
I'd say I'm sorry, but I'm not. Wasn't me, obviously. Someone should be, though.
[did they make that person pay? he does wonder. seems like part of an extended universe, slightly outside the scope of today's introductory book club session.]
no subject
maybe those who seek the dark will always think it kinder. ]
were you nervous?
when you started learning
no subject
[there's a smile on the other side, whether or not bob can guess at its existence. he tries to remember. 'nervous.' what a word.]
I'm afraid all the time. You can't care about something without being afraid to lose it. To believe otherwise disavows anything about people worth keeping.
Are you changing your mind?
no subject
oh no um
i’m
well i’m a little nervous i guess
[ hence the unassigned additional reading. ]
i’ve just been dealing with this stuff on my own for a while now
no subject
Has the worst thing you know to fear happened to you yet?
[—feels like normal conversational progression to him, somehow. he hits send.]
no subject
probably not?
[ there are always worse things waiting, etc. for bob, that’s been proven true over and over again. ]
but close
no subject
[that it can always be worse. half the horror of knowing what you're about is just horror. it's not alien to him, the need for reassurance. it doesn't seem weak in any way he eschews. the student wants to learn. that's the nature of the relationship—when you have the good fortune of not having to kill to claim what belongs with you.]
When I met you, you felt like someone who'd lost everything at some point. There's freedom in that. But I'm not trying to sell you nihilism or whatever the next philosopher will say. I just mean that it's opportunity to question the rules, the shape of the foundations, that built you in the first place.
Or not even opportunity. Necessity. Because you know it could happen again and time does not move in a circle. It's a spiral. You have a say in the direction of the drift, but none of us get to hide in a moment of reprieve.
What does this book say?
no subject
it says the shadow is neutral
and it reflects what i put into it
when i’m upset with it, it looks more frightening
so i should be more open minded about it
[ but consider i would not be so pissed at that guy if he would be helpful for once ]
no subject
[shit and sugar everywhere for those who know both are required for life itself. to grow. some more explosively than others, that's all.]
What about its purpose?
How he was made?
[it's not accidental, the switch in pronouns.]
no subject
i don’t know all the details
the place i’m from had these heroes to protect us for a long time, from dangers that were bigger and more powerful all the time, but we lost a lot of them
so he wasn’t supposed to exist
they were just trying to make somebody strong enough to protect everybody
i wasn’t the guy they wanted it to work on either, more like the first draft
[ to be discarded. ]
no subject
I'd say I'm sorry, but I'm not. Wasn't me, obviously. Someone should be, though.
[did they make that person pay? he does wonder. seems like part of an extended universe, slightly outside the scope of today's introductory book club session.]
How many other drafts were there?
no subject
thanks
[ for saying that. it matters every time someone does. ]
a lot
but nobody else survived it
no subject
Have you considered the possibility you survived because of him?